Will the Real Experts Please Stand Up
by Jennifer KushellOctober 28th, 2009
Lately there’s been a lot of murmuring online and at industry gatherings about this whole concept of what really makes an expert. To be blunt, the freewheeling use of the term is getting pretty out of control.
Everyone seems to be an expert in something these days. Whether it’s technology, social media, fitness, foreclosures…I’m pretty sure this explosive growth of authority figures is pretty universal among industries. My guess as to why is not just because people are looking for an edge, and some sort of competitive advantage, or unique identity that sets them apart, but the rise of citizen journalism and infopreneuring has something to do with it too. Millions of people now publish blogs, they self publish books, give seminars, start new departments for their companies…bottom line, they make money from packaging themselves as such. And more power to them for that!
Without pointing fingers or passing judgment (any further that is), I wanted to start to open a dialogue about what true expertise really means, so we can start holding all of ourselves to a higher standard, or, at very least, some minimal standards. It’s for the good of us all, seriously.
I’ll never forget the day I saw the caption under a big photo of myself in US News & World Report back in the mid 90s. I gasped. It said, “Talking About Her Generation – Guru: Get Ready for Change”. It was an article about my perspective on how our generation (Generation X) was inventing their own rules in business. (Little could we have imagined back then the tidal wave of change the Millennials would bring about a decade later!)
Despite the incredible endorsement from one of the most prestigious business magazines in the world, the innuendo that I was a “guru”, let alone an “expert” sent me into a panic. Who was I to be called a guru? How could I show my face around other, older, more established people? Sure, I’d been amassing a lot of experience over the preceding three or four years, was working with my peers from dozens of countries, had been consulting for big companies, doing a bunch of speaking engagements, working with a non profit or two, and was just getting started on my first book…but I was still so young and new to the field.
These are the principles that I’ve followed. I don’t expect others to live by the same standards, but this is what I did and it has certainly served me well in my career.
For whatever it’s worth, I studied (and lived by) this concept for years for my own sake, to ensure that no one ever questioned my own authority. Because I was just 19 when I started this career, gaining credibility and respect was a huge hurdle for me to overcome.
In an attempt to start to make people think more seriously about who they entrust with their time, money, health, well being and businesses, and for all of those who are building their expertise, or already holding themselves out as experts, I humbly offer this list. Consider this a guideline, an inspiration, or even a personal challenge. I know the definition of expertise is highly subjective, but allow me to set the bar high for us all.
1. Experience: You can’t build expertise without experience doing the actual work you talk about. Malcom Gladwell said it takes 10,000 hours. Other say it takes at least 3 to 5 years. But perhaps very significant experiences in a compact period of time can count for a lot too.
2. Education: A lot of fields require practitioners to complete certain academic courses, earn certificates or degrees, or complete a particular amount of training. The hours, month or years involved varies widely across industries. Know what’s relevant to you and comply as much as you can or make sure that your experience is compelling and substantive enough to compensate for a lack of formal training.
3. Being Paid: If you haven’t been paid for what you know, how can you validate that it’s valuable to others? Having clients or employers invest in you as a solution says a lot, especially when the outcome makes them happy and saves or makes them money. The more money you make from selling your expertise, the more credibility you gain.
4. Peer Recognition: Everyone is part of an industry, if not several different ones. If people in your industry vouch for you by endorsing your work, mentioning you in theirs, or inviting you into exclusive clubs or events, that’s substantive. The more prestigious and experienced the people who acknowledge you, the more meaningful it will be for many.
5. Media: Being quoted, profiled or featured by the media speaks volumes to thousands, if not millions, depending on the reach and respect of the medium. This is another third party endorsement that not only carries a lot of weight, but has high visibility and lends credibility from a trusted source.
6. Being Published: From blogs to podcasts, articles to books, there are lots of ways to package and promote your expertise. The more you do this and the more people who read and respond to your work, the bigger the outlets/publishers that will be eager to grant you access to their platform.
7. Exposure: How many people have read about you, come to see you speak, bought your products or services? How many know about you and your work? Gaining exposure is easier than ever if you leverage social media, but if no one knows about you, or can find you online, it’s easy to have your true authority questioned.
8. Authenticity: It should go without saying, but if you’re going to call yourself, or allow others to call you an expert, have the goods to back it up. If you live what you preach, it says as much about your integrity as your authority. There are far too many people in the world who attempt to teach others what they themselves have never accomplished or sell promises that they know will never or rarely be realized. Marketing is marketing, but worse than being a faux-expert is being a fraud. If you do nothing else, be authentic, honest and conduct your life and business with integrity.
There are lots of ways to build experience and earn credibility as an expert. Think about it. Consider your options and opportunities carefully. And take your definitions of expertise more seriously. Whether you’re a consumer relying on an expert, or the expert offering your services, everyone wins when relationships have a foundation of substance and demonstrable value.
Tags: credibility, experience, expert, how to build expertise, Jennifer Kushell, Your Success Network, YSN.com





October 28th, 2009 at 7:48 am
All solid points, Jen, and might I add a critical distinction of true experts who earn precious trust from others — deep down they are humbly NOT in it for themselves. They are all about sharing their “know what”, “know how” and most importantly “know WHO” to help advance the learning, progression and well-being of others. And helping others help others. It’s about relationships and being grateful every day for the honor to serve. Just like YSN and our “Circles of Change” radio/web show! Blog on … Z
October 28th, 2009 at 9:42 am
Here, here, Jen. This whole idea of “branding yourself” has become a double edged sword. It’s absolutely critical that people understand what they have to offer and to be able to clearly articulate that, but it’s another thing to package yourself to look good but once the layers get pulled back there’s nothing there or what you’re about has been rehashed/repackaged from someone else.
October 28th, 2009 at 9:47 am
Boy I couldn’t agree more – but when you find good information from good people – it really helps.
For example,
I am a huge fan of talk radio, and am also a business person constantly looking for sound ideas for income strategies. So when I heard Janet Switzer (marketing mogul for the Chicken Soup Series) on Conversations Live with Vicki St.Clair recently it was
really inspiring. Conversations Live with Vicki St.Clair is hosted on Seattle’s KKNW every Monday, noon PT.
On this segment, Janet Switzer introduced her new book called Instant Income: Strategies that bring in Cash for Small Businesses, Innovative Employees, and Occasional Entrepreneurs. The book and her radio interview shares some 20 years of marketing and advertising experience that’s invaluable. To learn all about her proven business tips for yourself, you can listen to the full podcast here:
http://conversationslive.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=188&Itemid=29
ENJOY!
October 31st, 2009 at 1:30 pm
Fantastic article, Jen, but more importantly – kudos to YOU for shining some light on front street and all the posers tap dancing on the pavement. I am an expert in one thing only – knowing what I’m not an expert in. “You know what you know and you don’t know what you don’t know” – I think Dick Cheney said that, and regardless of whether you do or don’t care for the smirky former Vice President, the statement is pure truism. I often (preferably) quote Margaret Thatcher who once said, “If you have to tell people you’re a lady, its probably because you’re not”.
I don’t care for self-proclaimed experts. I’m as hard on other people’s “expertise” as I am of my own. If you know more than the next guy, it only makes you an expert compared to him – but not in the broadest sense. I agree with your point – expertise is necessary – but broadly accepted standards are a must before we can identify who the real experts are. Lets have some real dialogue on measurements – both quantitative AND qualitative on how we, as people who seek the wisdom of the brightest and the best, set the bar.
Keep this conversation going and lets get some governing/certifying bodies to get in the mix.